Why Magic pursuing Klay Thompson in free agency is more of a dream than reality

Amidst the extensive discourse surrounding NBA offseason rumors, Tim Kawakami of The Athletic has identified the Orlando Magic’s alleged interest in Golden State Warriors sharpshooter Klay Thompson as an enticing possibility.

Kawakami wrote, “One of the league’s worst-kept secrets is that Orlando, which is loaded with young talent but lacks shooters, could offer Klay a ton of money next summer.”

The Magic have $66 million in contract space heading into the offseason, which significantly increases the appeal of acquiring a player of Thompson’s caliber.

Klay Thompson in a Magic jersey next to Franz Wagner and Paolo Banchero

Thompson’s fascination with The Magic is not without merit. Orlando is in critical need of an offensive boost at this time, as it ranks in the bottom half of the league in three-point shooting with an average of 11.1 per game at a rate of 35.3% and scores an average of 110.6 points per game. Thompson maintains a 38% shooting percentage despite experiencing his worst season from beyond the arc, placing him among the Magic’s top scorers.

By incorporating youthful talents like Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner into Orlando’s offensive strategy, Thompson’s three-point shooting percentage could potentially increase to 40 percent, evoking memories of his prime playing career. Joe Ingles was previously acquired by the Magic in an effort to bolster their perimeter shooting and add seasoned leadership. Thompson could similarly excel in this capacity, capitalizing on his experience winning championships to enhance the team’s competitive advantage.

Golden State Warriors guard Klay Thompson (11) dribbles the ball during the first quarter against the Utah Jazz at Chase Center.
Pursuit of Klay Thompson could impede the advancement of the Magic.

Nevertheless, pursuing Thompson, who presently earns in excess of $43 million, would impose a substantial financial burden. An investment of this nature could potentially limit Orlando’s capacity to expand its roster of talented individuals, as the organization considers Buddy Hield, Gary Trent Jr., Doug McDermott, and Malik Beasley as possible additions that could enhance the organization’s shooting efficacy while maintaining financial flexibility.

Caution is warranted due to Thompson’s age (34), injury history which includes missed seasons and a decline in performance during crucial playoff matchups. Significantly, Thompson’s performance in the most recent postseason highlights the potential drawbacks of depending on his former prowess.
In a decisive contest, he averaged 16.2 points on 34.3% shooting and scored an abysmal eight points on 3-for-19 shooting. In addition, his performance against the Boston Celtics in the 2022 NBA Finals was mediocre; he averaged 17 points on 35.6% shooting and finished Game 6 with 12 points on 5-for-20 shooting.

At this moment, the Magic are situated in third place in the Eastern Conference with a record of 46-32, trailing the Milwaukee Bucks by a single game on 47-31. With only four games remaining in the regular season, the Magic are in a situation where a razor-thin margin of error has the potential to significantly impact both their postseason seeding and momentum.

Golden State Warriors guard Klay Thompson (11) looks on from the bench in the final minutes of the second half of game six of the 2023 NBA playoffs against the Los Angeles Lakers at Crypto.com Arena.
Orlando’s current standing not only serves to emphasize their consistent competitiveness but also signifies that they are a unit poised to achieve a significant breakthrough. The results of these championship contests, especially considering their immediate consequences for standings and the possibility of facing formidable opponents such as the Milwaukee Bucks in-person meetings, will function as a critical evaluative period for forthcoming roster determinations in the summer.

Although the Magic’s pursuit of Klay Thompson is alluring, it is also fraught with potential pitfalls that concern long-term team development and strategic depth in addition to financial hardship. Therefore, the discourse surrounding Thompson’s potential arrival in Orlando continues to be an intriguing storyline, although it is more reminiscent of a fantastical scenario than the practical strategy necessary for the Magic’s continued expansion and triumph.